Loving Beirut for what it is – the dirt spread everywhere, the unexplainable and sudden lack of water in your apartment, the incredibly loud honking that follows you day and night from one corner of the city to the other, the bickering over taxi fares, the unavoidable leering eyes of men on the street, the heavily over-priced cell phones that makes you master of 30 second phone conversations, the army men at every corner of the street, the creamy ice cream covered in pistachios, the sojouk sandwiches that are surprisingly the most satisfying piece of food you've had all week, the mint tea that should really be drank in the company of friends (near the water preferably), the view of the sea while you lounge in the sun reading a book and thinking how the perfect blue pleasantly surprises you every time, the overpowering scent of jasmine trees that greets you when you enter a friend's house party on a Saturday evening, and the surprise lunar eclipse that looks down upon the line of people who stand willfully against the wall, entranced by the bright and half-hidden moon.
Beirut has taken me places, and this week it has been in pockets of pleasant surprises. One night, I enjoyed two amazing dinners – one at my other favorite restaurant (Barometer), consisting of fettoush, muttabbal, spiced potatoes, and chicken; and the second, only an hour after, at a friend's friend's house. Hommemade Lebanese food, good conversation, fantastic music and delicious desserts … well, how could there be anything wrong with that night?
Another night, the city took me to a fantastic Italian resteraunt in Gemmaizeh, where I gorged on pasta and friendly debates about the Olympics and Obama. I was at a table with an Australian, a Swede, a Norwegian, and two Americans, where my American pride came out more frequently than I thought it would.
And yet another night, I was saying good-bye to another intern who was leaving, and saying hello to a friend I had hardly seen all summer. At the party at his house, he showed me the garden he had worked on all summer, cleared away the rubble and uncovered a beautiful piece of land that looked like it could have been a small oasis in Gemmaizeh if it still retained its greenery and water. But they have big plans for it, he told me. The fountain would be repainted. Plants would be replanted. And that was the best note of the night: that a person who was just visiting Lebanon could love it so much to make even a small part of it beautiful again.
Yesterday I tried my hand at investigative journalism, traveling to a region 40 minutes outside of Beirut to uncover the causes of the forest fires spreading across the country. Even if we had not gotten a story, I would not have been disappointed. The wonderful company of three other interns and the discovery of a collection of life-size sculptures on the edge of a hill overlooking the valley, well that was more than enough.
Beirut does funny things to you. And last night, in the city's spirit of, "why not?", I resigned myself to become a poet for about five minutes when I read some of my poetry at a reading for the first time ever. And that was as good an end to the week as any...or the beginning of the week, depending on which way you look at it.
Monday, August 18, 2008
Tuesday, August 12, 2008
down we go
Countdown: 10 more days left.
I cannot believe how quickly the summer and the time in Lebanon have passed. Often I do not believe that people can change tremendously traveling abroad – how much can seven weeks really change a person? But I have been noticing that things are different, that my political thoughts are shifting, that parts of me, too, are not the same. And I realize, it is not so much a place that changes you, but the new circumstances that you are put in. One of my friends asked me earlier if I was “done” with Lebanon. I don’t know if one can be “done” with a place. I am looking forward to being home, and being in NYC after that. But Lebanon surprises me everyday.
Like last week – when our electricity (which goes out everyday for three hours), did so more frequently, to the point where my roommate and I had to sleep with no AC (which means open windows – nothing can say “welcome!” to mosquitoes more). Or when our we were without water for two days in our apartment, which meant having to run to nearby bars for a quick game of pool so we could use the restroom. Turns out everything is a blessing in disguise. The broken water pump incident led us to befriend our neighbor who, a musician, treated us to a private performance in celebration of our water coming back on. And then we started talking about politics, and he said he was a hezb. supporter, which made for interesting conversation.
I’m not sure if politics is everywhere in this country or if it is that I see it everywhere because that is what I have been trained to do. After all, reading the news or writing papers conditions one to look for specific signs, places them into labels of sects, religion, victims, oppressors, on and on and on. But something I have learned: although people have lived during war, they don’t necessarily live for war. People are more than Muslim or Christian or Jew or Palestinian or Israeli. Sometimes all they want is a hot shower for which they will dodge a bullet and be strip searched to get to (which happened to someone in May).
A friend and I traveled to the south last Saturday, with our limited Arabic. We hopped on a bus (at one point we were the only non-hijabis on the bus), and explored Saida, a town with a lot of history. When we got out of the bus station, we were greeted with bustling city streets – cars honking like they do in Beirut, and people with shopping bags hurrying from shop to shop. It was like being back in Beirut, but not as clean. After a quick look at the ruins of the sea castle, literally on top of the sea, we ventured into the heart of Saida. A walk through the tunnel of an old hotel housed in a 300 year old building, we were transported to a different world. The other side of Saida was more conservative, more like a village, more “traditional” (I can just see my soc/anth friends cringing). We spent quite a while walking around the souq area, our eyes savoring everything we saw, from clothing to souvenirs to whole goats skinned and hanging. We ventured further in search of the other castle and ended up walking around what seemed like an enclosed village, housing stores and homes in its building some hundred years old. People were a lot kinder in this part of Saida: a juice-seller letting us try jallab, a juice made of sweet berry popular in the Levant; a hunched old man, barely able to walk, showed us around the Great Mosque that had been subjected to its share of destruction and rebuilding. I forgot to mention, the South had been heavily attacked and fought in during the civil war. I am surprised at how many historical buildings are still somewhat standing. People have generally said there is nothing to see in Saida, that there is nothing special about it. But both my friend and I found it spectacular, perhaps because we were amazed at how different it was from Beirut.
An hour bus ride later, we were further south, to Tyre, to see Roman ruins, some that have withstood the test of time and war, and many that have unfortunately not. I was struck by how many cemeteries lined just one part of Tyre. While walking down one road, I passed by four…
Unfortunately I did not see everything I wanted to in Tyre. I probably not have a chance to visit again before the trip ends as I would like to go up North as well. But going down south, I was struck, again, by how close we were to Israel, to the conflict, how much Tyre had endured during the civil war and after.
As an outsider* I see Lebanon through its history; it is defined by its civil war, its period of relative peace, the 2006 war and the violence in May. To people here, the violence in May was just another war, peace was never really established in Lebanon, and that the country is always in a state of war. But, they say, so what?
Ah, I will try not to make the next post about war. It was unintentional but that is where my thoughts led me.
* No one considers me Pakistani or Indian. I’m either Lebanese or some sort of Middle Eastern they can’t quite place. It serves as a good mask sometimes. Like when taking taxis - if I'm angry enough and say where I'm going, the driver won't even suspect...
I cannot believe how quickly the summer and the time in Lebanon have passed. Often I do not believe that people can change tremendously traveling abroad – how much can seven weeks really change a person? But I have been noticing that things are different, that my political thoughts are shifting, that parts of me, too, are not the same. And I realize, it is not so much a place that changes you, but the new circumstances that you are put in. One of my friends asked me earlier if I was “done” with Lebanon. I don’t know if one can be “done” with a place. I am looking forward to being home, and being in NYC after that. But Lebanon surprises me everyday.
Like last week – when our electricity (which goes out everyday for three hours), did so more frequently, to the point where my roommate and I had to sleep with no AC (which means open windows – nothing can say “welcome!” to mosquitoes more). Or when our we were without water for two days in our apartment, which meant having to run to nearby bars for a quick game of pool so we could use the restroom. Turns out everything is a blessing in disguise. The broken water pump incident led us to befriend our neighbor who, a musician, treated us to a private performance in celebration of our water coming back on. And then we started talking about politics, and he said he was a hezb. supporter, which made for interesting conversation.
I’m not sure if politics is everywhere in this country or if it is that I see it everywhere because that is what I have been trained to do. After all, reading the news or writing papers conditions one to look for specific signs, places them into labels of sects, religion, victims, oppressors, on and on and on. But something I have learned: although people have lived during war, they don’t necessarily live for war. People are more than Muslim or Christian or Jew or Palestinian or Israeli. Sometimes all they want is a hot shower for which they will dodge a bullet and be strip searched to get to (which happened to someone in May).
A friend and I traveled to the south last Saturday, with our limited Arabic. We hopped on a bus (at one point we were the only non-hijabis on the bus), and explored Saida, a town with a lot of history. When we got out of the bus station, we were greeted with bustling city streets – cars honking like they do in Beirut, and people with shopping bags hurrying from shop to shop. It was like being back in Beirut, but not as clean. After a quick look at the ruins of the sea castle, literally on top of the sea, we ventured into the heart of Saida. A walk through the tunnel of an old hotel housed in a 300 year old building, we were transported to a different world. The other side of Saida was more conservative, more like a village, more “traditional” (I can just see my soc/anth friends cringing). We spent quite a while walking around the souq area, our eyes savoring everything we saw, from clothing to souvenirs to whole goats skinned and hanging. We ventured further in search of the other castle and ended up walking around what seemed like an enclosed village, housing stores and homes in its building some hundred years old. People were a lot kinder in this part of Saida: a juice-seller letting us try jallab, a juice made of sweet berry popular in the Levant; a hunched old man, barely able to walk, showed us around the Great Mosque that had been subjected to its share of destruction and rebuilding. I forgot to mention, the South had been heavily attacked and fought in during the civil war. I am surprised at how many historical buildings are still somewhat standing. People have generally said there is nothing to see in Saida, that there is nothing special about it. But both my friend and I found it spectacular, perhaps because we were amazed at how different it was from Beirut.
An hour bus ride later, we were further south, to Tyre, to see Roman ruins, some that have withstood the test of time and war, and many that have unfortunately not. I was struck by how many cemeteries lined just one part of Tyre. While walking down one road, I passed by four…
Unfortunately I did not see everything I wanted to in Tyre. I probably not have a chance to visit again before the trip ends as I would like to go up North as well. But going down south, I was struck, again, by how close we were to Israel, to the conflict, how much Tyre had endured during the civil war and after.
As an outsider* I see Lebanon through its history; it is defined by its civil war, its period of relative peace, the 2006 war and the violence in May. To people here, the violence in May was just another war, peace was never really established in Lebanon, and that the country is always in a state of war. But, they say, so what?
Ah, I will try not to make the next post about war. It was unintentional but that is where my thoughts led me.
* No one considers me Pakistani or Indian. I’m either Lebanese or some sort of Middle Eastern they can’t quite place. It serves as a good mask sometimes. Like when taking taxis - if I'm angry enough and say where I'm going, the driver won't even suspect...
Sunday, August 3, 2008
playing taboo
His cool and stone bedroom in the lower level of his house shelters Khalil Gibran's tomb, easily viewable in the small cave that guards it from human hands. His house, now a museum dedicated to his legacy, rests one of the hills of Bsharri, a Maronite Christian town that has served refuge for Christians throughout history. Inside his room, as a guide book tells us, is an attempt at a figure of the Jesus that Gibran imagined and wanted.
Gemmaizeh, which once used to be a street of small stores that were bombed and broken, is now a strip of bars, restaurants and cafes that invite those with unending energy to spend their nights bar hopping until the early hours of the morning - at times even past that. Downtown that once used to be a wasteland almost looks like a cross between story-book Paris and Disneyworld. In Hamra, broken streets have been replaced with vibrant college life and American and European stores. A taxi ride from one corner of the city to the other presents tall glass skyscrapers and construction for more tall glass skyscrapers.
When strolling around the city, it is also difficult to ignore the buildings dotted with bullet holes over their entire surfaces. These buildings are frequent, and at one time I thought they were perhaps left so people remember the fifteen year long civil war that overtook Lebanon. I am beginning to think that they are left standing only because of a lack of funds to tear them down straight away.
No one really talks about the war. There is no collective remembering, and in a conversation with a civil rights activist who I was interviewing for a completely unrelated story, I learn that he hasn't really talked about his memories of the war in a while before our meeting. He speaks of it casually. He describes waking up at 4 or 5 and standing in line for six hours for water; at times he would run back before the daily bombing started because he was unable to get water before curfew. "Whenever i see Picot cheese, it reminds me of the war."
Collective memory is actively silenced; he tells me history books don't document the war. They can't because one group or another will always be at fault.
After a week and a half of interviews, conversations and small trips, I cannot ignore something that I find is breathing heavily amidst the daily grind of this city: the fear of another war. In May, when violence broke out in Beirut, there was a great fear that it would start all over. In a taxi ride from Shatila, one of the major Palestinian refugee camps in Beirut that houses over 10,000 Palestinians, we pass by the place where the violence broke out in May. Near the area is an invisible divide between the fanatic Sunni area and the fanatic Shia area. But Lebanese, I am told, don't hold grudges. Fifteen hours after the violence ended in May, there was a festival for an arts performance. Daily life goes on.
But the war, the memory or the fear, is not easily forgotten. It came up, often unintentionally, in many conversations with people.
"I'm fed up with war." - 20 year old aspiring filmmaker
"We need to move past this country."
"I was not friends with a muslim until i was 19." - Christian who had grown up during the civil war. Beirut is so small, it is difficult to imagine how divided this country must have been to physically separate Sunnis, Shias and Christians so successfully.
"In Lebanon, we need war. Otherwise we get depressed."
"In the US, the future erases the past, whereas in the Middle East, the past erases the future." - in an interview about Obama, said by someone who had grown up during the war.
"I don't like Sunni Muslims" - the 'tour guide' who was showing us Shatila. She is Palestinian, and the reason she says this is because she has been lumped with Sunni Muslims as if the only groups that are really recognized are Sunnis, Shias and Christians. Palestinians have not only politically, but have socially been forgotten as well.
From a sarcastic poem written by a man who grew up during the war:
"Beirut is a panoramic stretch reeking of corruption and bullshit"
"People collect weapons in houses they havent' used ...yet" (at this point, the audience that had been laughing grew quiet)
"with so much repetition the words she was saying lost their meaning"
"survival in civil war is always accompanied by guilt"
"let's go to the end of history, right now."
Gemmaizeh, which once used to be a street of small stores that were bombed and broken, is now a strip of bars, restaurants and cafes that invite those with unending energy to spend their nights bar hopping until the early hours of the morning - at times even past that. Downtown that once used to be a wasteland almost looks like a cross between story-book Paris and Disneyworld. In Hamra, broken streets have been replaced with vibrant college life and American and European stores. A taxi ride from one corner of the city to the other presents tall glass skyscrapers and construction for more tall glass skyscrapers.
When strolling around the city, it is also difficult to ignore the buildings dotted with bullet holes over their entire surfaces. These buildings are frequent, and at one time I thought they were perhaps left so people remember the fifteen year long civil war that overtook Lebanon. I am beginning to think that they are left standing only because of a lack of funds to tear them down straight away.
No one really talks about the war. There is no collective remembering, and in a conversation with a civil rights activist who I was interviewing for a completely unrelated story, I learn that he hasn't really talked about his memories of the war in a while before our meeting. He speaks of it casually. He describes waking up at 4 or 5 and standing in line for six hours for water; at times he would run back before the daily bombing started because he was unable to get water before curfew. "Whenever i see Picot cheese, it reminds me of the war."
Collective memory is actively silenced; he tells me history books don't document the war. They can't because one group or another will always be at fault.
After a week and a half of interviews, conversations and small trips, I cannot ignore something that I find is breathing heavily amidst the daily grind of this city: the fear of another war. In May, when violence broke out in Beirut, there was a great fear that it would start all over. In a taxi ride from Shatila, one of the major Palestinian refugee camps in Beirut that houses over 10,000 Palestinians, we pass by the place where the violence broke out in May. Near the area is an invisible divide between the fanatic Sunni area and the fanatic Shia area. But Lebanese, I am told, don't hold grudges. Fifteen hours after the violence ended in May, there was a festival for an arts performance. Daily life goes on.
But the war, the memory or the fear, is not easily forgotten. It came up, often unintentionally, in many conversations with people.
"I'm fed up with war." - 20 year old aspiring filmmaker
"We need to move past this country."
"I was not friends with a muslim until i was 19." - Christian who had grown up during the civil war. Beirut is so small, it is difficult to imagine how divided this country must have been to physically separate Sunnis, Shias and Christians so successfully.
"In Lebanon, we need war. Otherwise we get depressed."
"In the US, the future erases the past, whereas in the Middle East, the past erases the future." - in an interview about Obama, said by someone who had grown up during the war.
"I don't like Sunni Muslims" - the 'tour guide' who was showing us Shatila. She is Palestinian, and the reason she says this is because she has been lumped with Sunni Muslims as if the only groups that are really recognized are Sunnis, Shias and Christians. Palestinians have not only politically, but have socially been forgotten as well.
From a sarcastic poem written by a man who grew up during the war:
"Beirut is a panoramic stretch reeking of corruption and bullshit"
"People collect weapons in houses they havent' used ...yet" (at this point, the audience that had been laughing grew quiet)
"with so much repetition the words she was saying lost their meaning"
"survival in civil war is always accompanied by guilt"
"let's go to the end of history, right now."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)